I recently pulled out my springform pans to test out cheesecake options for Thanksgiving because I am so over blah pumpkin pie, and decided that these cool pans needed more use beyond the cheesecake. And I love the spaghetti pie at Old Chicago but never seem to end up going there. So I decided to try making spaghetti pie at home with my springform pans.

This recipe is for an 8" springform pan, but this recipe is fairly forgiving if you're good an experienced enough cook to eyeball and want to use different sized springforms. I have an 8", a 9" and two smaller 4" ones. Personal sized ones in the 4" pans would be too cute!

There are a lot of steps here but it comes together easily, just read through everything first and have all of the ingredients ready to go.

Print Pin

Spaghetti Pie

Make a spaghetti pie just like the ones at Old Chicago, but you can get a whole pie instead of one slice when you make this recipe! It's as customizable as at the restaurant, but this cheesy marinara drenched version is my favorite!

Course Main Course

Keyword marinara, pie, spaghetti

Servings 8 servings

Author April

Equipment

one 8" springform pan

Ingredients

1 12 oz. box of spaghetti
1 24 oz. jar of marinara or your preferred tomato-based sauce
4 tbsp unsalted butter
¼ cup flour
2 cups milk
1 cup heavy cream
2 cups of an Italian cheese blend buy a bag or grate your own combination of mozzarella, Parmesan, provolone, Romano, and asiago, cheeses
1 cup extra grated Parmesan cheese
Dash of nutmeg
Optional garnishes: pepperoni fresh basil, pesto, chopped tomatoes)

Instructions

Cooking your own pasta sauce? Get it started if so, using your favorite recipe. Using a jarred version? Warm it up in a small saucepan over low heat.
Boil the spaghetti according to package directions in a large pot.
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
Divide out 1 cup of cheese blend and ¼ cup of Parmesan in a bowl and set aside. Pour the rest of the Parmesan in with the bigger portion of cheese blend.
In a medium sized pot, melt the butter over medium heat.
Measure out the milk and heavy cream so it’s ready to go.
Once the butter is melted, whisk in the flour, keeping the motion going so that there are no lumps.
When the flour and butter are thoroughly combined, slowly pour in the milk. Slowly add in the cream, still whisking!
Bring the heat up to medium high, and continue whisking, but you can be a bit less constant.
Add the dash of nutmeg at this point, and salt and pepper if desired.
Slowly begin adding the larger portion of the cheese blend to the cream mixture. Keep whisking til the cheese has melted and turn off the heat.
At this point, drain the spaghetti but reserve 1 cup of pasta water.
Remove 1 cup of cheese sauce from the rest and set aside.
Mix the spaghetti and remaining cheese sauce in the large spaghetti boiling pot. Combine thoroughly, using the pasta water to thin the sauce as needed so every strand is coated.
Dump the spaghetti-cheese mixture into an ungreased, locked 8″ springform pan. Use a large spoon to even out the top.
Bake for 20 minutes.
Remove from oven and spread remaining cheese sauce on top. Top with remaining Parmesan and cheese blend.
Bake for 10 more minutes.
Remove from oven and let rest for 10 minutes before running a knife around the edge to loosen the baked on cheese topping from the edges.
Unlock the springform pan and gently remove the outer part of the pan from the pie. Use the knife to coax loose strands as needed.
To serve, put as much pasta sauce as you desire on a plate, then use a large, sharp knife and pie server to place a piece of pie on the sauced plate. Garnish as desired.

Sure, that's a lot of steps but they are easy ones overall. I made this on a weeknight with no problem! This recipe is worth it, makes a ton of leftovers that can be jazzed up in tons of ways, and this bad boy reheats fantastically in a microwave. And this looks super cool at a dinner party... even if there's a gooey delicious cheese leak.